Agriculture in Sustainable Rural Development
Table Of Contents
- <p> <b>TABLE OF CONTENTS</b><br></p><p> Abstract ....................................................................................................................................... i </p><p>Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................... ii </p><p>List of Figures ........................................................................................................................... vi </p><p>List of Tables ............................................................................................................................. vi </p><p>List of Photos ........................................................................................................................... vii </p><p>List of Appendices ................................................................................................................... vii </p><p><b>Abbreviations and Acronyms .................................................................................................. viii </b></p><p><b>
Chapter ONE
INTRODUCTION
- ............................................................................................................................. 1 </b></p><p>
- 1.1Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 1 </p><p>
- 1.2Proposition, Research Objective and Research Questions ............................................... 2 </p><p>
- 1.3Empirical Presentation of Study Area .............................................................................. 3 </p><p>1.
- 3.1Location and Size ...................................................................................................... 5 </p><p>1.
- 3.2Climate and Vegetation ............................................................................................. 6 </p><p>1.
- 3.3Economy .................................................................................................................... 6 </p><p>
- 1.4Smallholder agricultural Production in Ghana and in the Ejisu-Juaben Municipality ..... 7 </p><p>
- 1.5The Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategy II (GPRS II 2006-2009). ........................ 10 </p><p>1.
- 5.1Private Sector Competitiveness ............................................................................... 11 </p><p>
- 1.6Method in Brief .............................................................................................................. 13 </p><p> 1.
- 6.1Research Strategy .................................................................................................... 13 </p><p>1.
- 6.2Research Design ...................................................................................................... 13 </p><p>1.
- 6.3Data Analysis .......................................................................................................... 14 </p><p><b>
Chapter TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
- ........................................................................................................................... 17</b></p><p>LITERATURE REVIEW and THEOTETICAL FRAMEWORK ......................................... 17 </p><p>
- 2.1Literature Review ........................................................................................................... 17 </p><p>2.
- 1.1Role of Agriculture in Sustainable Development ................................................... 17 </p><p>2.
- 1.2Is the Pursuit of Agricultural Productivity the Ultimate Panacea for Rural Development? ................................................................................................................... 21 </p><p>2.
- 1.3The GPRS II on Smallholder Agricultural Productivity ......................................... 24 </p><p>2.
- 1.4Climate Change Adaptation in the Smallholder Agricultural Sector ...................... 27 </p><p>2.
- 2.Theoretical Framework ................................................................................................. 28 </p><p>2.
- 2.1A Framework for Policy-Livelihood Relationships ................................................ 28</p><p> 2.
- 2.2Assets ............................................................................................................................... 29 <br></p><p>2.
- 2.3Transforming Structures and Processes ........................................................................... 30 </p><p>2.
- 2.4Livelihood Outcomes ....................................................................................................... 30 </p><p>2.
- 2.5Livelihood Strategies ........................................................................................................ 30 </p><p>2.
- 2.6Vulnerability Context ....................................................................................................... 31 </p><p>2.
- 2.7Conceptual Framework of Sustainable Livelihoods Dynamics .............................. 31 </p><p><b>2.3 Operationalisation of Key Concepts .............................................................................. 34 </b></p><p><b>
Chapter THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
- ........................................................................................ 37 </b></p><p>
- 3.1Research Design and Method ......................................................................................... 37 </p><p>3.
- 1.1Data and Sample ...................................................................................................... 38 </p><p>
- 3.2Qualitative Method ......................................................................................................... 40 </p><p>
- 3.3Quantitative Method ....................................................................................................... 41 </p><p>3.
- 3.1Methods of Quantitative Analysis ........................................................................... 41</p><p>
- 3.4Ethical Issues .................................................................................................................. 46 </p><p>
- 3.5Limitations of the Study ................................................................................................. 48 </p><p><b>
Chapter FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
- ........................................................................................................................... 51 </b></p><p>PRESENTATION OF EMPIRICAL FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS ................................ 51 </p><p>PART 1: Agricultural Development Policy – Monitoring MOFA’s Compliance to the Action Plan .............................................................................................................................. 52 </p><p>
- 4.1The National Level and Local Level Crop Development Policy of the GPRS II .......... 53 </p><p>
- 4.2Alignment with Stakeholder Concerns .......................................................................... 61 </p><p> PART 2: Interaction through Participation – Beneficiaries’ Level of Policy Awareness........65 </p><p>
- 4.3Beneficiary Farmers: Active Participants in Agricultural Productivity and Development of their own Livelihoods? .................................................................................................... 65 </p><p>4.
- 3.1Farmers Participation: The Demand Side ................................................................ 66 </p><p>4.
- 3.2Roles of MOFA: The Supply Side of Participation ................................................ 71 </p><p>
- 4.4Implications of Demand and Supply of Participation in Municipal Level Decision Making for Agricultural Productivity: Farmers’ Empowerment? ........................................ 75 </p><p>PART 3: LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC WORKING CONDITIONS FOR SMALLHOLDER FARMERS ......................................................... 78 </p><p>
- 4.5Local Environmental Conditions ................................................................................... 78 </p><p>4.
- 5.1Local Knowledge and Perceptions on Climate Change .......................................... 80 </p><p>
- 4.6Local Socio-Economic Working Conditions ................................................................. 84 </p><p>4.
- 6.1Labour ..................................................................................................................... 86 </p><p>4.
- 6.2Capital ..................................................................................................................... 87 </p><p>4.
- 6.3Credit ....................................................................................................................... 90 </p><p> 4.
- 6.4Land ......................................................................................................................... 93 </p><p>4.
- 6.5Production levels – Including Crop Yields and Producer Prices of Crops ............. 95 </p><p>
- 4.7Livelihood Adaptation Assessment ................................................................................ 96 </p><p>4.
- 7.1Local Adaptation to Climate Variability ............................................................ 97 </p><p>4.
- 7.2Local Adaptation to Adversely Changing Socio-Economic Work Conditions ..... 100 </p><p>PART 4: Monitoring Overall Impact: Productive Capital Assets of Smallholder Farmers ................................................................................................................................................ 102 </p><p>
- 4.8Livelihood Asset Status Tracking Assessment ............................................................ 102 </p><p>4.
- 8.1Natural Capital ...................................................................................................... 103 </p><p>4.
- 8.2Financial Capital ................................................................................................... 105 </p><p>4.
- 8.3Physical Capital ..................................................................................................... 107 </p><p>4.
- 8.4Human Capital ....................................................................................................... 109 </p><p>4.
- 8.5Social Capital ........................................................................................................ 111 </p><p>4.
- 8.6Aggregated Assessment ........................................................................................ 114</p><p>
- 4.9Links between Farmers’ Capital Asset Development and Livelihood Resilience ....... 120 </p><p><b>
Chapter FIVE
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
- ......................................................................................................................... 123 </b></p><p>SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............ 123 </p><p>
- 5.1Conclusion .................................................................................................................... 123 </p><p>
- 8.2Recommendations ........................................................................................................ 130 <br></p><p> <b>Bibliography ......................................................................................................................... 133</b></p><p><b> Appendices ............................................................................................................................ 139 </b> <br></p>
Project Abstract
<p></p><p></p> <b>ABSTARCT </b><p></p><p>The Poverty Reduction Strategy (PRS) approach championed by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund lies at the centre of development assistance, debt relief, and development planning in many developing countries, including Ghana. Ghana has implemented a PRS (Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy I, 2003-2005) and a second generation of PRS (Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategy II, 2006-2009) had just passed its implementation phase in 2009. This study focuses on the second PRS – that is the Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategy II (GPRS II). The study also selectively reviews major literature on the role of agriculture in sustainable rural development and offers critical perspectives on realising the potential multiplier effects of sustainable agriculture in sustainable rural development promotion. In Ghana, agriculture continues to be one of the dominant sectors of the economy, in terms of its contributions to output, employment, revenue generation, and foreign exchange earnings, and yet many of the poorest in Ghana, like in many developing countries, are farmers usually practising smallholder rain-fed systems which are highly vulnerable to shocks. Meanwhile, the specific nature of thematic areas of the GPRS II such as improving agricultural productivity and its effects on livelihoods of poor and vulnerable groups such as food crop farmers has received little academic attention. This study responds to this gap by offering a theoretically informed empirical research directed towards the better understanding of the effects that the agricultural productivity sub-sector of the GPRS II has had on smallholder farmers’ ability to develop sustainable livelihoods. Often, variability in climatic conditions interacts with adverse socio-economic conditions such as disadvantageous terms of trade and poor agricultural infrastructure to undermine agricultural productivity and by extension, farmers’ livelihoods (Sagoe, 2006). The study adopted an analycentric approach to policy analysis of the GPRS II focusing on the micro-scale of typically farming communities in the Ejisu-Juaben municipality of the Ashanti region of Ghana. Livelihood analysis conceptual and methodological frameworks were also employed to assess the livelihood resilience building capabilities of local smallholder farmers due to effects of the GPRS II. It was revealed that although many of the interventions in the municipality’s action plan seemed to conform to the most critical empirical needs of local farmers for resilient livelihood development, the GPRS II has not duly benefited the greater majority of farmers in the municipality, and thus been slow in its poverty reduction processes. A livelihood resilience analysis for instance revealed that although a few smallholder farmers were able to develop productive capital assets and to build viable and sustainable livelihoods through the activities of the GPRS II, a greater majority of smallholder farmers in the municipality have not been able to adequately develop capital assets for more productivity, hence maintaining extremely poor and vulnerable livelihoods. <br></p>
Project Overview