Effect of Plant Growth Regulators in the Rooting of Pinus Cuttings
Table Of Contents
Project Abstract
<p>
<b>ABSTRACT </b></p><p>This work evaluated the rooting of Pinus caribaea var. hondurensis Morelet cuttings under the action of different
levels of plant growth regulators. The cuttings consisted of 4-6 cm long shoots of P. caribaea var. hondurensis
Morelet with their basal needles removed. The basal part of the cuttings were treated for 2 seconds with the
following treatments 1- NAA 2000mg L-1; 2- NAA 4000mg L-1; 3- NAA 6000mg L-1; 4- NAA 2000mg L-1 + PBZ
100mg L-1; 5- NAA 4000mg L-1 + PBZ; 6- NAA 6000mg L-1 + PBZ; 7- IBA 2000mg L-1; 8- IBA 4000mg L-1; 9- IBA
6000mg L-1; 10-IBA 2000mg L-1 + PBZ; 11- IBA 4000mg L-1 + PBZ; 12- IBA 6000mg L-1 + PBZ; and a control.
After receiving the treatment, the cuttings were planted in tubes containing 50% carbonized rice hulls and 50%
vermiculite. The evaluations, performed 60 days after planting, showed that P. caribaea var. hondurensis cuttings
treated with IBA produced a higher percentage of rooted cuttings than those treated with NAA; the most effective
treatment was IBA 4000mg L-1 plus 100mg L-1 paclobutrazol. </p><p><b>Key words Auxins, paclobutrazol, Pinus caribaea
</b>
<br></p>
Project Overview
<p>
<b>INTRODUCTION </b></p><p>Cloning or vegetative propagation of trees has
been a useful tool in traditional tree improvement,
and the great promise of clones is for production
forestry (Libby, 1986). The majority of
gymnosperms, especially in the genus Pinus, are
sexually propagated by seeds. With regard to large
scale propagation and preservation of selected
genetic characters, sexual reproduction poses a
risk of loss of these characteristics. On the other
hand, vegetative propagation is the form by which
desired individual characteristics are maintained,
resulting in a plant that is genetically identical to
the original donor plant, thus becoming the
preferred method of propagation (Oliveira, 1989).
Conifers may be vegetatively multiplied in several
different ways, for example via grafting, cuttings,
adventitious shoots or somatic embryos.
Comercial production of Pinus radiata by tissue
culture methods is in development in New Zealand
(Gleed, 1985). Propagating plants with particularly
desirable characteristics is a very common practice
in horticulture, used extensively with some
forestry species, particularly in high productivity,
fiber farming systems (e.g., plantations of hybrid
poplars, eucalyptus, and Caribbean pines). Rooting
in Pinus cuttings depends on a series of factors
that can be controlled by cutting collection time,
cutting size, whether the needles are kept or not,
condition and age of the source plant, plant
nutritional condition, prunning, type and health of
the cutting, season when the cuttings are collected,
rooting-promoting treatments, condition and type
of substrates, irrigation, moisture, temperature, and
other factors (Silva, 1985).
The process of root formation at the base of a
cutting may be divided into three stages: initiation,
elongation of root initials, and root growth and
development (Hartmann et al., 2002). Three
groups of chemicals may be applied to regulate
and/or influence the rooting process in some way:
a) hormones, which induce the initial meristematic
activity (Wiesman et al., 1989; Davis and Haissig,
1990) and stimulate the elongation and
development of roots formed (Hartmann et al.,
2002; Wiesman et al., 1989); b) nutritional
elements which promote growth of the new roots
(Wiesman and Lavee, 1995); c) protecting agents,
such as biocides, which enable the cuttings to
resist attack by pathogens during the entire rooting
period.
Studies on the physiology of auxin action showed
that auxin was involved in such varied plant
activities as stem growth, adventitious root
formation (Went, 1934; Haissig and Davis, 1994),
lateral bud inhibition, abscission of leaves and
fruits, and activation of cambial cells. Indole-3-
acetic acid (IAA) was identified as a naturally
occurring compound having considerable auxin
activity (Haissig and Davis, 1994). IAA was
subsequently tested for its activity in promoting
roots on stem segments, and in 1935, investigators
demonstrated the practical use of this material in
stimulating root formation on cuttings (Thimann
and Koepfli, 1935). About the same time it was
shown (Zimmerman and Wilcoxon, 1935) that two
synthetic materials, indole-3-butyric acid (IBA)
and α-naphthalene acetic acid (NAA), were even
more effective than the naturally occurring or
synthetic IAA for rooting. Today, IBA and NAA
are still the most widely used auxins for rooting
stem cuttings and for rooting tissue-cultureproduced microcuttings. It has been repeatedly
confirmed that auxin is required for initiation of
adventitious roots on stems, and indeed, it has
been shown that divisions of the first root initial
cells are dependent upon either applied or
endogenous auxins (Strömquist and Hansen, 1980;
Gaspar and Hofinger, 1988). IBA has been found
to occur naturally.
The formation of root primordium cells depends
on the endogenous auxins in the cutting and on a
synergic compound such as a diphenol. These
substances lead to the synthesis of ribonucleic acid
(RNA), which act upon root primordium initiation
(Hartmann et al., 2002). The application of some
plant growth retardants, together with auxin, has
been used to improve the rooting capacity of
cuttings in some species (Pan and Zhao, 1994;
Wiesman and Lavee, 1995). Triazoles have been
reported to affect some physiological processes
during rooting (Davis and Haissig, 1990; Wiesman
and Lavee, 1995). Paclobutrazol (triazol), a
gibberellin synthesis inhibitor (Rademacher et al.,
1984), keeps the gibberellin levels in the cuttings
at low values; gibberellins are considered
substances that inhibit rooting (Hartmann et al.,
2002). Moreover, paclobutrazol increases the sink
capacity at the base of the cutting for
carbohydrates and/or hormones (Wiesman and
Lavee, 1995). Thus, the objective of this work was
to analyze the rooting potential of Pinus caribaea
var. hondurensis Morelet cuttings under the action
of different concentrations of plant growth
regulators. </p><p><b>MATERIALS AND METHODS</b> </p><p>Pinus caribaea var. hondurensis Morelet shoots
were collected from a clonal garden. The cuttings
were 4 to 6cm in length with the basal needles
eliminated. Later, the cuttings were treated with
plant growth regulators, planted in tubes and taken
to a intermitent mist system in a enclosed
polyethylene propagation house for 60 days. The
cuttings were treated with two auxins, indole-3-
butyric acid (IBA) and α-naphthalene acetic acid
(NAA), and with paclobutrazol (PBZ), by
immersing the base of the cuttings in a gel solution
for 2 seconds. The following treatments were
used: 1- NAA 2000mg L-1; 2- NAA 4000mg L-1;
3- NAA 6000mg L-1; 4- NAA 2000mg L-1 + PBZ
100mg L-1; 5- NAA 4000mg L-1 + PBZ; 6- NAA
6000mg L-1 + PBZ; 7- IBA 2000mg L-1; 8- IBA
4000mg L-1; 9- IBA 6000mg L-1; 10- IBA 2000mg
L
-1 + PBZ; 11- IBA 4000mg L-1 + PBZ; 12- IBA
6000mg L-1 + PBZ; and a control.
<br></p><p>
After treatment, the cuttings were planted in tubes
containing 50% carbonized rice hulls and 50%
vermiculite. Evaluations were performed 60 days
after planting, including: rooting percentage, total
sugars contents, reducing sugars contents and
phenol contents. The biochemical analyses were
conducted with cutting samples on the day the
experiment was started and at the end of the
experiment. The total phenol content analysis in P.
caribaea var. hondurensis cuttings was performed
according to the official method prescribed by the
Association of Official Analytical Chemists -
A.O.A.C. (1984), adapted by Skorupa et al.
(1998). The total sugars and reducing sugars
analyses were performed by the Somogy-Nelson
method (Nelson, 1944).
The experiment was carried out as a completely
randomized design with 13 treatments containing
4 replicates with 8 cuttings each. The data were
submitted to analysis of variance (F test) and the
means compared by Tukey test at the 5%
probability level. The data were transformed into
arc sin sqrt((x + 0.5)/100) for statistical analysis.<b> </b></p><p><b>RESULTS AND DISCUSSION</b> </p><p>Percentage of rooted cuttings
A significant difference in NAA concentrations (F
= 19.89) was observed for P. caribaea cuttings.
The rooting percentage in the NAA 2000 mg L-1
treatment (53.13%) was higher than in other
treatments (Table 1), therefore, indicating that this
plant growth regulator was effective in promoting
rooting in cuttings of this species. NAA at 4000
and 6000 mg L-1 showed lower rooting
percentages. The increase of NAA concentration
was accompanied by the rooting percentage
decrease, suggesting that high NAA
concentrations were phytotoxic for the root
formation process. Thus, it could be suggested that
the concentration that promoted the highest
rooting percentage was between 0 and 2000mg L-1
.
Through statistical analysis, it was observed that a
significant difference occurred between treatments
containing IBA and the control (F= 24.20), but no
difference was observed between the different IBA
concentrations used. A value of 95.31% rooted
cuttings were observed at the concentration of
4000 mg L-1 IBA (Table 2). With regard to
treatments with and without PBZ, no significant
differences were observed, i.e., they did not
contribute towards the root regeneration process.
According to Wiesman and Lavee (1995),
paclobutrazol applied in combination with IBA
increased the rooting capacity of cuttings, by
increasing root formation. This plant growth
retardant has effects on the partition of
photoassimilates, on the water status of the
cuttings, and has been described as a promoter of
adventitious roots in many species (Steffens and
Wang, 1986). Paclobutrazol, in addition to
stimulating root growth, as also mentioned by
Davis et al. (1985) and Steffens and Wang (1986),
increased rooting potential in this work.</p><p>
Table 1 - Average rooting percentage of Pinus caribaea var. hondurensis Morelet, submitted to NAA treatments
with and without the addition of paclobutrazol (PBZ).
Treatments with PBZa
without PBZa
Meana, b
Control 31.25 ns
NAA 2000mg L-1 59.38 46.88 53.13 Ba
NAA 4000mg L-1 18.78 9.38 14.08 Bb
NAA 6000mg L-1 0.00 15.63 7.81 Bb
Mean 26.05 A 23.96 A
C.V.= 41.75%
aMeans followed by different capital letters in the rows and small letters in the columns are significantly different (Tukey test at
p≤0.05); ns= non significant.
bMeans followed by different capital letters in the mean column are significantly different of the table 2 mean column (Tukey test
at p ≤ 0.05). </p><p>
The percentage results of rooted cuttings treated
with NAA or IBA showed that cuttings treated
with IBA presented, significantly, a higher root
formation response in comparison with NAA (F=
6.90), suggesting that this auxin was more
effective in initiating roots in this species at these
concentrations. Nelson et al. (1992), using four
different auxins (IAA, IBA, NAA, and indole-3-
propil) in P. taeda, P. elliotti var. elliotti, and P.
palustris showed that IAA and IBA presented
good results, while NAA and indole-3-propil
showed poorer results in the rooting of cuttings of
these species. When IBA is applied to stem
cuttings or microcuttings to stimulate rooting, it is,
in part, converted to IAA (Vander Krieken et al.,
1992). IBA may also enhance rooting via
increased internal-free IBA, or may synergistically
modify the action of IAA or the endogenous
synthesis of IAA; IBA can enhance tissue
sensitivity for IAA and increase rooting (Vander
Krieken et al., 1993).
According to Hartmann et al. (2002), IBA is the
best auxin for general use because it is nontoxic to
plants over a wide concentration range than NAA,
and is effective in promoting rooting of a large
number of plant species.
Total Sugars Content
There was a significant difference between the
control and the other treatments (F= 18.82 and F=
75.51, respectively) for P. caribaeae cuttings
treated with either NAA or IBA. A significant
interaction was also observed between NAA or
IBA concentrations and the addition or not of PBZ
(F= 8.32 and F= 5.44, respectively) on total sugars
content.
Cuttings treated with 4000 mg L-1 NAA + PBZ
and 6000 mg L-1 IBA showed the lowest total
sugars content, while those treated with 2000 mg
L
-1 NAA and 4000 mg L-1 IBA + PBZ showed the
highest total sugars content (Tables 3 and 4). The
same treatments showed the highest rooting
percentages (Tables 1 and 2). The total sugars
content analysis in Pinus cuttings, immediately
after they were prepared, before being placed in
the rooting medium was 14.63%. Thus, a
reduction higher than 50% in total sugars content
from the beginning of the rooting process until the
evaluation period was observed, indicating the use
of these sugars in the process.
Reducing Sugars Contents
The statistical analysis showed a significant
difference between treatments with NAA or IBA
and the control for reducing sugars content. In
treatments with NAA there was a significant
interaction between NAA concentrations and the
presence or not of PBZ. Among the NAA
treatments, 6000 mg L-1 NAA and 2000 mg L-1
NAA + PBZ showed the highest reducing sugars
contents, while the lowest content was shown by
the 2000 mg L-1 NAA treatment. The treatments
containing IBA at 6000 mg L-1 and IBA at 2000
mg L-1 showed the lowest and highest reducing
sugars contents, respectively (Tables 5 and 6). </p><p>Table 2 - Mean rooting percentage of Pinus caribaea var. hondurensis Morellet cuttings, submitted to IBA
treatments with and without the addition of paclobutrazol (PBZ).
Treatments with PBZa without PBZa Meana, b
Control 31.25*
IBA 2000mg L-1 93.75 84.38 89.06 Aa
IBA 4000mg L-1 100.00 90.63 95.31 Aa
IBA 6000mg L-1 78.13 84.38 81.25 Aa
Mean 90.63 A 86.46 A </p><p>C.V.= 23.11%
a
Means followed by different capital letters in the rows and small letters in the columns are significantly different (Tukey test at
p≤0.05). *significant at p≤ 0.05.
bMeans followed by different capital letters in the mean column are significantly different of the table 1 mean column (Tukey test
at p ≤ 0.05). </p><p>Table 3 - Mean total sugars contents in Pinus caribaea var. hondurensis Morelet cuttings, submitted to NAA
treatments with and without the addition of paclobutrazol (PBZ).
Treatments with PBZa without PBZa Meana
Control 6.56*
NAA 2000mg L-1 4.86 Ba 7.61 Aa 6.23
NAA 4000mg L-1 3.91 Bb 6.81 Ab 5.36
NAA 6000mg L-1 4.71 Ba 6.22 Ab 5.47
Mean 4.49 6.88 </p><p>C.V.= 6.42%
aMeans followed by different capital letters in the rows and small letters in the columns are significantly different (Tukey test at
p≤0.05). *significant at p≤ 0.05.
<br></p><p>
The reducing sugars content analysis before
initiation of the rooting process was 3.2%; thus, a
small increase in this content was observed,
probably because of the conversion of total sugars,
since reduction occurred, into reducing sugars.
<br></p>