Prediction of Runoff and Sediment Yield Using AnnAGNPS Model: Case of Erer-Guda Catchment, East Hararghe, Ethiopia
Table Of Contents
Project Abstract
<p> <b>ABSTRACT</b></p><p> Land and water resources degradation are the major problems in Ethiopia. Poor land use practices and improper
management systems have been playing a significant role in causing high soil erosion rates, sediment transport and loss of
soil nutrients. In this study a physically based watershed model, AnnAGNPS model was applied to the Erer-Guda river
catchment for prediction of runoff and sediment yield. The objectives were to evaluate the AnnAGNPS model capability to
predict the runoff and sediment yield with respect to different land use practice factors and to identify the most erodible
sub-catchment of Erer-Guda gauged catchment of East Hararghe zone. Sensitivity analysis, model calibration and
validation were also performed to assess the model performance. Four sensitive parameters were identified of which curve
number (CN) was the most sensitive one. For model calibration, model efficiencies of 0.758, -331.068 and 0.710 were
observed for surface runoff, peak runoff rate, and sediment yield, respectively. Corresponding coefficient of determination
were founded to be 0.825, 0.110 and 0.763, respectively. Runoff and sediment yield were well predicted but, peak runoff
rate was over predicted. Validation results produced model efficiencies (NSE) as 0.778, -77.999 and 0.779 for surface
runoff, peak runoff rate and sediment yield, respectively. The coefficient of determination (R2) as 0.923, 0.235 and 0.857
for runoff, peak runoff rate and sediment yield, respectively. Surface runoff and sediment yield simulation were found
better in validation stage as well as the peak runoff rate showed almost the same as for calibration. Erer-Guda catchment
was simulated with respect to land use practices for runoff and sediment yield generation. Cultivated agricultural land was
contributed large amount of runoff and sediment yield. Runoff and sediment yield from the contributing land use was
486mm/yr and 10.50t/ha/yr, respectively. Erer-Guda catchment was divided in seven sub-catchments. Runoff and sediment
yield for each sub-catchment were quantified. The result of simulation of runoff and sediment yield after calibration for the
most erodible sub-catchment (SWT-5) was 498.41mm/yr. and 17.30tons/ha/yr. respectively. In conclusion, the
AnnAGNPS model can effectively be used to predict runoff and sediment yield in order to effectively design soil and
water related development in absence of gauged information.
Keywords Runoff, Sediment Yield, Estimation, and Model
<br></p>
Project Overview
<p>
1. INTRODUCTION </p><p>Rainfall-runoff-sediment yield is the most
complex hydrological phenomenon to comprehend due to
tremendous spatial variability of watershed characteristics
and precipitation patterns, making the physical modeling
quite complex and involved. The quantity of runoff and
sediment yield resulting from a given rainfall depends
mainly on rainfall intensity, duration, and distribution
besides others, such as initial soil moisture, land use,
slope, etc. The runoff is critical to many water resources
activities, for example, design of flood protection works,
protection of agricultural lands, planning of water storage,
etc. The erosion in the watershed may be occurred due to
rainfall and runoff, and degrades its land. The sediment
transport caused the reduction of storage capacity of rivers
and reservoirs [2].
<br></p><p>
In Ethiopia, soil and water are the most critical
natural resources. Nearly 85% of the population depends
on subsistence agriculture. One process that threatens the
resource base is soil erosion. Studies have shown that
billions of tons of soil are lost annually [48]. Due to
greater population pressure and consequently more
intensive cultivation, erosion losses have been increasing
to an annual areal average of 7 ton/ha equivalent to depth
0.5 mm [22]. Local erosion rates are highly spatially
variable ranging from less than 1 to over 400 tons/ha/year
[26, 28, 31 and 45]. The high variation in soil loss might
be due to variations in slope, rainfall, soil type, land use,
plot size and method of estimations. Beside soil losses,
rainwater loss in the form of runoff is an important
production constraint.
The poor land use practices, improper
management systems and lack of appropriate soil
conservation measures have been major causes of soil
erosion and land degradation problems in Ethiopia.
Because of the rugged terrain, the rates of soil erosion and
land degradation in Ethiopia are high. In addition to this,
the combined effects of deforestation, overgrazing,
expansion of cropland and unsustainable use of natural
resources have contributed to land degradation [14].
<br></p><p>
Soil erosion has a serious ecological impact that
costs a nation due to both on-site and offsite damages.
Three major universal impacts of erosion are reduction in
productivity of crops, flood hazards, and the decrease of
the life expectancy of water storage structures [15].
Sediment degrades water quality, and carries soil
adsorbed polluting chemicals. Sediment deposition in
irrigation canals, stream channels, reservoirs, water
conveyance structures, reduces their capacity and would
require costly operation for removal [21].
In order to formulate management options, soil
erosion must be considered. Soil loss from a watershed
can be estimated based on an understanding of the
underlying hydrological process in a watershed, climatic
conditions, landforms and soil factors. One option for
formulating management options is to use models to
elucidate processes controlling the hydrologic and
sediment fluxes.
Assessing and mitigating soil erosion at the
watershed level is complex both spatially and temporally.
Soil type, depth, and location, land cover type and
management, topology and other factors make the
watershed a complex system where hydrologic and
erosive process may differ greatly over a small spatial
scale. Knowledge of rainfall, runoff, and soil loss, and
their relationships as well as variation in time and space
are very important for soil and water management such as
designing soil and water conservation and water
harvesting structures [42].There are many event based that
continuously simulate stream flow, erosion/sedimentation,
or nutrient loss from a watershed. However, few models
have been developed or tested in the monsoonal climates
of Ethiopia. </p><p>To estimate soil erosion and develop optimal soil
erosion management plans, many erosion models such as:
Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) [49], Water Erosion
Prediction Project (WEPP) [20], Soil and Water
Assessment Tool (SWAT) [3]. European Soil Erosion
Model (EUROSEM) [33] and AnnAGNPS [5] have been
developed and used over many years. Among these
models, the USLE has remained the most practical
method of estimating soil erosion potential and to estimate
the effects of different erosion factors on soil erosion.
USLE has been used for more than 40 years [12; 29]
whereas other process-based erosion models developed
afterward have limitations in applicability due to intensive
data and computation requirements. However, studies
using the USLE do not consider the sediment delivery
ratio to estimate the sediment delivered to the downstream
point of interest [30]. As a result, more recent physicalmodels for soil erosion estimation have been developed
that consider the sediment delivery process.
Therefore, physical-based hydrologic models are
required for studying hydrological process and
hydrological responses to land use and climatic changes.
AnnAGNPS is a continuous-simulation,
physical-based, watershed-scale model intended to be
used as a tool to evaluate non-point source pollution from
agricultural watersheds ranging in size up to 300,000 ha
[5]. The physically based distributed watershed models
have higher accuracy in analyzing the impact of land
management practices on water and sediment yields in
large complex watersheds. The selection of AGNPS for
the project was based on the capability of the watershed
approach to assess the impact of conservation planning,
including BMPs, to reduce sediment loadings to ErerGuda catchment. It incorporates the most current
methodologies used by NRCS such as the Revised
Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE) [38] and Soil
Conservation Service (SCS, now NRCS) hydrologic
procedures [44]. In addition, AnnAGNPS provides the
ability to aid in the identification and evaluation of
sources of water and sediment production within the
watershed.
There is a knowledge gap with respect to the
interdependence between the runoff and sediment yield
and watershed on different temporal and spatial scale in
Erer-Guda river catchment. The magnitude of sediment
transported by the upper Erer-Guda catchment has
become a serious concern for planning, design and
implementation of numerous national development
projects in the area. Furthermore natural vegetation has
been almost cleared for agricultural crop production.
Shrubs covers small area in the catchment and classified
as deciduous and dry forest with medium and small trees
including bushes, and some scattered trees showing
evidence of former natural forest. Reduction in the soil
production capacity, change in river bank and flooding
due to sediment deposition are problems calling for
estimation of annual runoff and sediment yield in upper
Erer-Guda river catchment. Although a number of
researchers have conducted erosion studies in Ethiopia,
the lack of compelling tool or method has hindered
adoption and implementation of their findings [36; 46].
Both mathematical and parametric methods require a lot
of information, which is a major constraint in many
developing countries [46]. These countries have no
appropriate and accurate soil erosion prediction models
although universal soil lose equation (USLE) is used in
different tropical countries [34]. </p><p>Assessment of
Annualized Agricultural Nonpoint Source (AnnAGNPS)
Pollution model for predicting runoff and sediment yield
in Upper Erer-Guda river catchment is imperative.
The general objective of this study is to provide a
basis for future scenario analysis of water resource
management of Erer-Guda River.
The specific objectives of this study were: to
evaluate the AnnAGNPS model capability to predict the
runoff and sediment yield in Erer-Guda river catchment,
and to assess the sediment yield and runoff generation
with respect to different land use practice and to identify
the most erodible sub-catchment of Erer-Guda river
catchment.
<br></p>