EFFECTS OF FAULTY DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION ON BUILDING MAINTENANCE
Table Of Contents
Thesis Abstract
<p></p><div><b> ABSTRACT</b></div><div>The study examined the effects of faulty design and construction on the maintenance of building. A survey of randomly selected samples of
35 builders and 20 architects were conducted. Questionnaires were used to collect data from Architects and Builders. The survey included 4 groups of
defects and sub defects in each groups. The predominant severity effects of each defects was assessed and ranked based on the severity index as
ranked by both the Builders and the Architects. The results shows that 16 defects were rated as most severe, 19 as moderately severe and 12 defects
as slightly severe defects, however according to the builders 15 defects were rated as most severe defects, 28 defects as moderately severe and 3
defects as slightly severe defects. The results also show that increase in maintenance work is the most predominant effects on building maintenance
among other factors of defect with an index value of 100.00 as perceived by both the rank of the Architects and that of the builders. The research
however includes a hypothesis that Architects and Builders generally agree on the ranking of the severity defects which was tested and proven to be
true. The study concluded that there should be a design review before finally approving the design for construction; maintenance expert should not be
overlooked in the planning stage of the project and most importantly the employment of professionals for any building projects.
<p>
<br></p></div>
Thesis Overview
<p><b>1.0 INTRODUCTION</b></p><p><b>1.1 BACKGROUND OF STUDY</b></p><p>The relationship between design, construction and
maintenance is closely related but not easily distinguished.
Hardy and lammers (1996: cited in maisarah 2012) explained
the vital role of design in the early stage of project
management. They stated that a functional design can
promote skill; economy, conveniences, and comforts while a
non-functional design can impeded activities of all types of
detract from quality of care, and raise cost to intolerable
levels. A typical saying by Vonnegut (1922-2007)’ every body
want to build and no body want to do maintenance. In Nigeria
building design are copied from other countries without
considering the conditions that lead to such design, hence
maintenance experts are seldom included to advice on
maintenance efficiency of such design. In a related
development iyagba (2005) reveal that there are substantial
numbers of people who do not know the meaning of
maintenance. The mistakes most designer made is believing
that a building that is design with the best aesthetics materials
requires little or no maintenance, but such notion or argument
are wrong because The maintenance of a building begins
after the construction is completed (Haniff, 2007).</p><p> Eizzatul
‘Ain (2012) observed that the maintainability aspect at the
design stage is often ignored and this has contributed to
future problems when implementing maintenance work. He
further explained that this happens when the aesthetics value
has become more important in the design of asset, besides
the design factor, site selection, apparatus, tools or facilities
to maintain the asset are hard to obtain or very costly.
According to Rozita (2006) the effectiveness of the building is
not dependent on its aesthetic value but on the ability to
perform maintenance works on the building in the future. Just
like the military slogan that if you fail to plan, and then you are
planning to fail. That is, if a building is design and constructed
without any plan for maintenance the building is hovering
towards failure. </p><p>According Norhaniza etal(2007) if the
designer failed to plan well the entire plan would also fail.
Every decision made during the building design and
construction has its own impact, too often the professionals
that constructs and design don’t worry whether the building
they design and build will work properly, their major concern
is just to complete the project and move to the next job while
the consequence is left for the client to handle. The effect of
faulty building design and construction has become one of the
major issues in maintaining building in Nigeria. United nation
(1992) mentioned that the world as pass a demographic
milestone i.e. for the first time in the history of mankind. World
Bank suggested that urbanization and resulting housing
problems are the most dominant phenomenon in all
developing countries. But a fact indicated that urban
population forms an overwhelming majority in all developed
countries, (World Bank, 1990). Nigeria has a population
estimated to be around 150 million which has the largest
black populace in the world and as such new building are
being built daily to accommodate the demands of the teeming
population, this has lead to the desperation of every single
individual to have a building of his own , the consequence is
that an inexperience designer is given a contract to design
and same to another to construct in a short period of time
which will result in many defects especially during the design
and construction stage and this will inevitably result in high
maintenance cost.</p><p> Abdulmohsen and sadi, (1997) stated that
the increase in maintenance cost is attributed to the failure of
the building design. If we compare the production of as cars,
for example a car is designed and then built; it is tested
exhaustively, fault identified and then rectified. If we relate this
to building work, we need to construct a building, test if
overtime and then demolish and rebuild, removing all problem
in the next design. Faulty construction also accounts for many
building failure, if a new copied design has not been specified
or built previously(most especially designed copied from
abroad) the builder will have no experience of this design and
may build it incorrectly resulting in high cost of maintenance
with inherent defects. It is therefore sacrosanct for both the
designer and the builder to consider the importance of
maintenance at the onset of the design because decision
made at the planning stage have a large effect on the
maintenance of the building and the cost. It is most times
worry some that most building expert that suppose to educate
the public on the importance of building maintenance will say
age building result in high cost of maintenance. It is most time
correct but we should also know that there are some new
building with numerous defect as a result of faulty design and
construction which previous research work estimated to
surpass the cost of maintaining the age building. Dauda and
muyiwa (2010) found out that defects within new building are
area of non compliance with the building code of practice
older buildings or building out of warranty period may not
comply with theses standards but must be judged against the
standard at the time of construction or refurbishment.
<br></p><p>
<b>1.2 STATEMENT OF PROBLEM</b></p><p> Most public buildings in Nigeria are in a state of derelict
conditions of structural and aesthetic disrepair and if
corrective measures are not properly carried out, it could
results in a total breakdown of structural component. Despite
the various strategies being adopted by the government for
the maintenance of those facilities, the buildings remain a
home for defects that should have been avoided if proper
feasibility planning on maintenance has been given
cognizance right from the design and construction stage of
the project. This has led to unnecessary expenditure from the
various authorities in carrying out remedial work to curb the
effects. Brennan (2000) opined that the main purpose of
maintenance of property is essentially to retain it values for
investment, aesthetics, safety and durability with a view to
ensuring that the property is continually used for habitation
and to satisfaction of the owner. It was even observed that
majority of the new construction were being built up with
defects which later transpire into substantial expenses on
maintenance
<br></p><p>
<b>1.3 AIM OF STUDY</b> </p><p>The aim of this study is to gain an understanding if the Effects
of faulty design and construction on Building maintenance </p><p><b><i>1.3.1 Objectives of the study</i> </b></p><p>1. To identify the building defects caused by faulty
design and construction on building maintenance</p><p> 2. To assess the effects of the building defects caused
by faulty design and construction on maintenance</p>